Neither King Nor Country by Alan Kay (From The Picton Gazette)

[The following article appeared in The Picton Gazette on July 15, 2019. I am reproducing the full article as a favour to the author. While I haven’t read the book myself, it does come with some great recommendations, which are posted after the article ends. ~James]

Loyalist connection leads American author to Prince Edward County

A highly decorated high school history teacher from the United States paid a visit to the heart of Loyalist country earlier this month.

And there was certainly something serendipitous about Alan Kay discussing the research into his historical fiction novel Neither King Nor Country in the offices of Canada’s oldest community newspaper on the day reserved for celebrating his home country’s independence.

The visit to Prince Edward County and the surrounding area held in high value by Loyalist descendants such as the landing place in Adolphustown is part of a reckoning this proud patriot and fan of George Washington has been undertaking over the last decade or so.

A man whose efforts were recognized by the Daughters of the American Revolution as the Outstanding American History Teacher of the Year in 2002 has found part of his family took part in the northern migration after the colonial revolt in the mid to late 1700’s and a page turning read that should appeal to readers on both sides of the 49th parallel is the fruits of that deep dive into the pages of his own family history.

“I have always tried to present a balanced approach both as a historian and as a teacher to my students and present both sides of the picture,” Kay said of his teaching efforts.

A natural history buff, Kay became enthralled with George Washington during a fourth grade reading assignment and the native New Englander who now teachers in Tarpon Springs, FL even spent time researching the first US president at Mount Vernon.

Family folklore had Kay as a distant relative of fellow founding father John Adams.

But as he started to look up his family genealogy, a startling discovery was awaiting Kay.

It wasn’t John Adams, the second US President and subject of the popular HBO mini series that Kay was related to but rather John Adams, a Loyalist whose family settled in the British North America portion of the Maritimes and later had an island off the coast of Newfoundland named for him.

The proud American who’s life revolved around history and had always taken great pains to present a creative and balanced approach to the crucible moment of his native land now had a whole new perspective and lens to examine the past through.

And that research has lead to Neither King Nor Country , a novel featuring the fictional Rob Callahan, an average middle aged teacher and rec league hockey player from the northeast who is about to undergo a seemingly predestined transformative journey-whether the main character wants to or not.

“It’s kind of a personal journey, the character sometimes reflects myself and other times doesn’t,” Kay said.

Kay’s research into his own familial path and the crafting of the well-written book has had a side benefit for his students in that the educator has been able to provide more pieces of the Loyalist experience following the fallout of the American Revolution.

“We’ve had the students take sides and rehash the arguments and actions right down to the tarring and feathering,” Kay said. “One of my characters in  Neither King Nor Country, a person that was on the fence as to whether to join the revolution or stay loyal, witnesses a public tarring and feathering in person and he was abhorred by it all- the act and the barbaric behaviour that took on the spectacle of the coliseum and it leads the character to the Loyalist side.”

Having toured the Maritimes previously with visits to Loyalist landing places in New Brunswick and Nova Scotia, Kay said he was very impressed with this area and how names and dedications seemed to reciprocate his former stomping grounds in the New England area.

“It’s interesting that Prince Edward County reflects our experiences in New England and the colonies. We have the Minutemen Parkway, we have the revolutionary historical sites and museums in Virginia, we have the plaques in all these towns and public spaces and here you have not only the Loyalist traditions and settlement area but you also have Tyendinaga close by and (the indigenous people) obviously played role on both sides as well. You’ve got everything here. Loyalist remembrances are everywhere but, at the same time, they are subtle and natural and it’s all very tasteful,” Kay added.

See also  An Impalpable Certain Rest by Jeff Bursey

And the settings are perfect- at least this time of year for a transplanted Yankee who enjoys the school year climes in the sunny south.

“It’s truly breathtaking in terms of natural beauty. We visited Lake-On-The-Mountain and we said “Wow, the King of England truly gave the Loyalists an absolute paradise’. Of course this the summer time and we know what comes next,” Kay said with a laugh.

With the benefits of hind sight, descendants of Loyalists tend to speak proudly of their ancestors making the trek to this sparsely populated, at times cruel and unyielding region and setting down new roots.

But that side of American history that tore families and friends apart isn’t exactly dinner table discussion in the homes of our long lost U.S. cousins.

“Americans don’t really like talking about it or discussing the Loyalists and really haven’t up until about 20 years ago,” Kay said. “My character finds out that his family was divided and he really doesn’t want to talk about it our discuss it with anyone at first but I think the time is coming where we in the United States are are ready to discuss and get deeper into what happened and see how it played it out from the other side and maybe this book could be a starting piece to that larger discussion.”

To read an interview with Mr. Kay, please visit Allan Hudson’s The South Branch Scribbler here.

*Please note if you choose to purchase this book (or Kindle version) through Amazon using the link below we will receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. If you cannot see the Amazon ad below (if you are using an ad blocker, for instance) here is the link: Thanks!

More praise for Neither King Nor Country:

Modern day treasure hunt into history

There is excitement, drama, action, politics, and even a little lust in this new release by Alan Kay that takes place in both present day and the 18th & 19th centuries. It will appeal to lovers of mystery, adventure, history…and hockey players! When teacher/hockey player, Rob Callahan, discovers an old family letter written by Ben Franklin’s son, William, his search for more information begins a treasure hunt type quest that takes him, two women, two sons, and a litany of others chasing them across the border into Canada. It is a fun, action filled read with descriptions of beautiful east coast Canada that will entice the reader to put the area on their bucket list of places to see.

Ms.  Penny Cathey
AP American History Teacher (retired)

A loyalist perspective

This was truly a fun and engaging read. Informative as well as entertaining, the author has provided readers with a deeply researched depiction of everything from Canadian manners and mores, to ice hockey, to the American Revolution. He is especially adept at helping readers understand the emotional toll that a war dividing Americans from one another took. Truly a fine book. One very minor quibble. Benjamin Franklin was not illegitimate. His son, William was indeed a “bastard,” as was William’s son.

Dr. Sheila Skemp
Professor emeritus of history at the University of Mississippi

Owner/Editor-in-Chief at -- Website

James M. Fisher is the owner and editor-in-chief of The Miramichi Reader. The Miramichi Reader (TMR) —Canada’s best-regarded source for the finest in new literary releases— highlights noteworthy books and authors across Canada from coast to coast to coast (est. 2015). James works and resides in Miramichi, New Brunswick with his wife and their tabby cat.

Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Alan N. Kay
April 21, 2020 12:44

Thank you James for this posting! I am excited to talk with all readers!

July 20, 2020 09:08

[…] of the popular book review website, The Miramichi Reader. You can read TMR’s write-up HERE. Alan has agreed to a 4Q Interview and is sharing an Excerpt from his novel. FROM […]

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x