Categories: Fiction

The Punishing Journey of Arthur Delaney by Bob Kroll

I dove into this book assuming that it was going to be bleak – I mean, the title is The Punishing Journey of Arthur Delaney, and it’s not a metaphor – but wow, Bob Kroll held back no punches with this one. It is dark and tragic and very bleak, and if you’re looking for a fairy tale ending, I will spoil and tell you not to bother, but I will also say that despite the bleakness of the story, it’s a rewarding read. Kroll’s spare prose and eye for accuracy in a sweeping story set in the 19th century resulted in a rich, haunting story. It’s not pleasant, nor is it an easy read, but it is one that I’ve thought about repeatedly in the days since I’ve finished reading it.

Arthur Delaney is distraught when his wife Mary dies. Without an idea of what to do and how to take care of three children, he leaves his children in the care of an orphanage and goes off to fight in the American Civil War. During the war, he gets put into a Confederate prison and spends three years there. Making his way up the American east coast, Delaney does a number of odd jobs in order to have the money to sail home to Halifax and get his children back. But when he finally makes it to Halifax, he finds out that Miss Golding, the head of the orphanage, has indentured his children out, and they’re lost to him. Delaney is newly crushed, and he embarks on a Canada-wide walk to find his children, wherever they may have ended up. Interspersed with snapshots of Delaney’s travels through the decades are chapters about each of his three children: Jimmy, who runs away from his indenture and ends up working in logging camps; Robina, who gets accused of murdering the man who bought her indenture, spends some time in jail, and then goes on her own long walk to find a life; and Annie, who was saved from jail by Robina and ends up adopted by a kind family. Each child has a very different, lonely existence, wandering in their own way.

While this is bleak, it’s not that this story is without sparks of hope and joy. It’s realistic: as nice as it would be to have a fairytale ending to this, it ties up well but not without lingering regret and pain. Kroll brings us into a harsh world, where the ramifications of Delaney’s actions reverberate through time and space, but at its centre is a truly remorseful person. How rare is it to have a character who genuinely commits themselves to fixing a horrible mistake! And for all of the coarseness and brutality throughout the novel, there is a great deal of tenderness. This is a powerful novel, and one I recommend you stick with, even though it will challenge you.


Bob Kroll studied history at Providence College and the University of New Brunswick. He worked on farms and in the woods before settling into a forty year writing career. His previous books include The Drop ZoneThe Hell Of It All, and Fire Trap. He lives in Halifax, Nova Scotia.

  • Publisher ‏ : ‎ ECW Press (June 7 2022)
  • Language ‏ : ‎ English
  • Paperback ‏ : ‎ 224 pages
  • ISBN-10 ‏ : ‎ 1770416331
  • ISBN-13 ‏ : ‎ 978-1770416338

*The Miramichi Reader encourages you to shop independent! However, shopping at a bookstore is not always possible, so we are supplying an Amazon.ca link. Please note if you choose to purchase this book (or Kindle version) through Amazon using the link below we will receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. If you cannot see the Amazon ad below (if you are using an ad blocker, for instance) here is the link: https://amzn.to/3ypgR5H Thanks!


Alison Manley

Alison Manley bounced around the Maritimes before landing in Miramichi, NB, where she works as a hospital librarian. She has an honours BA in political science and English from St. Francis Xavier University, and a Master of Library and Information Studies from Dalhousie University. When she's not reading biomedical research for her work, she likes reading poetry, contemporary and historical fiction, and personal essays. Noted for a love of bright colours (and lipstick), you can find her wandering the banks of the Miramichi River with a book and a paintbrush.

Recent Posts

Rig Wives by Kelly Earle

Kelly Earle’s husband, who works offshore in the oil industry, inspired her to write Rig…

7 hours ago

The Art of Misadventure: The Outtakes and Mistakes Of An Adventurous Photographer by Dave Brosha

Join Canadian photographer, explorer, Fellow of the Royal Canadian Geographical Society, father, and writer Dave…

7 hours ago

Patterson House by Jane Cawthorne

Alden Patterson, the last living member of a once-wealthy Toronto family, is haunted by the…

15 hours ago

Weekly Ferocity: October 1, 2022

Weekly Ferocity is a weekly feature of The Miramichi Reader, containing four original aphorisms by…

15 hours ago

My Name is Seepeetza by Shirley Sterling

An honest look at life in an Indian residential school in the 1950s, and how…

2 days ago

Unrest by Emma Côté

Brisk, observational, and darkly comic, Unrest is both a road trip story and a touching…

2 days ago

This website uses cookies.