Tom Ryan’s Return to Breakneck Island is a standalone sequel to The Treasure Hunters Club, and is set on the rugged coast of Maple Bay, and nearby Breakneck Island, complete with dangerous rocks and a solitary lighthouse. Told in a dual timeline, the novel is both contemporary and harkens back to events that took place in 1932. The reader is immediately drawn in with a dramatic prologue that entices with its romantic description of the area, ultimately focusing on Louis MacLeary mending a net and observing his father. A sense of unease immediately pervades the scene:
Even from this distance, Louis can see that his father’s fingers are busy working with a bundle of cord, typing and untying and retying knots, a sure sign he is thinking something through, no doubt assessing the state of things on Breakneck, as always. Knots. A fine hobby for a man who is tied so tightly to his life. It occurs to Louis that his father is like the birds. He had a chance to be free, but the island reeled him back….Bowline. Clove hitch. Figure eight. Brian MacLeary’s fingers slip the line over and into itself with a smooth, mindless precision, creating space in his mind to think and think.
As the story unfolds, we learn that the MacLeary family maintained the lighthouse on the Island until 1932 when a strong storm swept across the island and the entire family mysteriously vanished. Over the years, rumours and speculation about the fate of the MacLearys persisted, with no resolution.
As the story unfolds, we learn that the MacLeary family maintained the lighthouse on the Island until 1932 when a strong storm swept across the island and the entire family mysteriously vanished.
The contemporary portion of the storyline includes a small handful of characters who are drawn to the mystery, determined to see if they can find answers to the enigmatic events of 1932, with a vague hint that there might be hidden treasure as an added incentive.
A series of narrative threads are woven together that continue the reader’s engagement. An eccentric but loveable artist named Cookie is murdered for an inexplicable reason. Cookie’s relationship to Dandy and her somewhat errant father Pinch form one direction, while romances between Peter and Victor, Cass and Bryson, Dandy and Parker take another. Delightful characters abound, including the irascible Buzz and all of the well-drawn MacLearys.
The 1932 storyline is rich with gangsters, rum smuggling, and intrigue. As we progress closer to understanding what happened to the individuals who vanished without a trace, we meet new characters very near to the end of the book.
She’s carried just two names during her 102 years on earth, but she’s lived countless lives. A student and a traveller, a nurse and a gardener, a friend and a lover, a wife and a widow, a mother and a grandmother and a great-grandmother, many times over. These days, when she tries to remember the people she knew, they sometimes blend together, and when she squints and casts about for a particular moment from a particular time in her life, it refuses to surface from the murky depths of her mind.
Layer upon layer of intrigue and tension are woven together in this compelling and charming mystery. The 1932 narrative is particularly gripping and tenderly explores family dynamics even while the disturbing events that led to their disappearance take place.
In all, lyrical description contrasts beautifully with convincing dialogue in this novel, which is replete with red herrings, plot twists and exciting episodes. Recommended.
Tom Ryan is the author of two adult mysteries, the internationally bestselling The Treasure Hunters Club, which was a 2025 Edgar nominee for the Lilian Jackson Braun Award, and We Had a Hunch, which Publishers Weekly called “criminally good fun”. He is also the author of the YA mystery Keep This to Yourself, winner of the 2020 ITW Thriller Award for Best Young Adult Novel, the 2020 Arthur Ellis Award for Best YA Crime Book, and the 2021 Ann Connor Brimer Award. His YA follow-up, I Hope You’re Listening, was the winner of the 2021 Lambda “Lammy” Award for Best LGBTQ Mystery. Tom, his husband, and their dog live in Nova Scotia.
Publisher: Simon & Schuster (October 6, 2026)
Paperback 9″ x 6″ | 368 pages
ISBN: 9781668224441
Lucy E.M. Black (she/her/hers) is the author of The Marzipan Fruit Basket, Eleanor Courtown, Stella’s Carpet, The Brickworksand Class Lessons: Stories of Vulnerable Youth,and A Quilting of Scars. The Mural will be released in April 2027. A retired educator, her award-winning short stories have been published in Britain, Ireland, USA and Canada. Lucy co-ordinates Heart of the Story, an author reading series, writes reviews for The Miramichi Reader and serves as Writer-in-Residence for Scugog Memorial Library. She lives in the small lakeside town of Port Perry, Ontario, the traditional territory of the Mississaugas of Scugog Island, First Nations.









