A Meredith Island Mystery
In A Cruel Cold by Alice Fitzpatrick, readers once again return to Meredith Island in Wales. It is Christmas, and author (and sometimes amateur detective) Kate Galway is looking forward to her daughter Alex’s holiday visit. Kate is imagining an idyllic time of mother-daughter bonding, holiday traditions and a much needed respite from Alex’s demanding life as a lawyer. Instead, once the ferry to the island arrives, Kate is surprised to learn that her ex-husband James has invited himself to join them for a few days. Also on the ferry is a small gaggle of visitors who are likewise crashing the festive celebrations.
The ferry, lit up with strings of lights, its deck packed with islanders returning from shopping and visitors excited to spend the holidays with friends and family, had rounded the lifeboat station and were coming into view. Front and centre stood a tall, white-haired man gazing at the cliffs that swept around the beach toward the harbour.
One of the island’s regulars and a popular matriarch is the elderly Sophie Sutherland. Sophie is beloved by everyone on the island and the community is excited to know that a beau from her youth is arriving to spend the holidays with her. The romantics are hoping that Sophie will finally have her happily-ever-after with Teddy Bartell, a well-known horticulturalist with whom she has remained in touch throughout their adult lives.
For the past hour, Sophie had been debating where to place herself when Teddy arrived. Sitting in the drawing room might make her appear like royalty presiding over an official audience. Greeting him at the door could make her seem too eager, undignified for a woman of her age. Perhaps she shouldn’t have agreed to this visit. In her mind, he’d remained a skinny twenty-one-year-old student, with a fresh, unlined face, searching the island for plants to press and study. They’d spent so much time in the Bluebell Woods, he’d called her his Bluebell, a name he’d used in the Christmas and birthday cards he’d sent since they’d parted. She feared he’d be expecting a young woman and would be disappointed with her age spots and thick waist.
Teddy duly arrives on the ferry boat but is unexpectedly also accompanied by his son, his son’s wife and his brother-in-law, all of whom appear eager to participate in the festivities. However, each of them has a darker agenda. While the entire community is forgathered at the local pub, one of the visitors suddenly drops dead from an apparent poisoning. The island access has been shut down due to winter storms and the only authorities available to investigate are Kate and her ex-husband, James who is a Detective Chief Inspector on the mainland.
With no labs or police support, James relies on his ex-wife and daughter to help him catch the killer. Exciting and unexpected twists and turns spill over one another as the story unspools and the motivations and driving forces behind each of the individuals are revealed.
A touching and tender love story is delightfully woven into this cozy mystery and, as is usual with Fitzpatrick’s deft hand, the writing is fast-paced, descriptive and crisp. Each of the characters is memorable and we are given teasers about a fourth book as their story trajectories are clearly not at a close. An engaging and accomplished cozy mystery. Highly recommended.
Exciting and unexpected twists and turns spill over one another as the story unspools and the motivations and driving forces behind each of the individuals are revealed.
Alice Fitzpatrick has contributed short stories to literary magazines and anthologies, including the Crime Writers of Canada 40th anniversary anthology, Cold Canadian Crime. She is a fearless champion of singing, cats, all things Welsh, and the Oxford comma. Her summers spent with her Welsh family in Pembrokeshire inspired the creation of the Meredith Island Mysteries which include Secrets in the Water and A Dark Death (finalist for the 2026 Crime Writers of Canada award for Best Traditional Mystery). Alice’s latest book, A Cruel Cold, is an homage to Agatha Christie. The traditional mystery appeals to her fascination with what makes seemingly ordinary people commit murder. Alice lives in Toronto but dreams of a cottage on the Welsh coast.
Publisher: Five Arches Press (September 3, 2026)
Paperback: 5″ x 7″ | 300 pages
ISBN: 9781067865702
Lucy E.M. Black (she/her/hers) is the author of The Marzipan Fruit Basket, Eleanor Courtown, Stella’s Carpet, The Brickworksand Class Lessons: Stories of Vulnerable Youth,and A Quilting of Scars. The Mural will be released in April 2027. A retired educator, her award-winning short stories have been published in Britain, Ireland, USA and Canada. Lucy co-ordinates Heart of the Story, an author reading series, writes reviews for The Miramichi Reader and serves as Writer-in-Residence for Scugog Memorial Library. She lives in the small lakeside town of Port Perry, Ontario, the traditional territory of the Mississaugas of Scugog Island, First Nations.









